General Forums >> Controversial Topics >> Is it harder for women of color?
Is it harder for women of color?
| back to top |
Posted 12 months ago From the collective experience of this group : do women of color get slammed with the double negative, or is gender discrimination color-blind? |
| back to top |
| Posted 11 months ago Without a doubt, I think there are definitely stereotypes which effectively compound the difficulty women face today (when applying for jobs, expressing public opinions, and so on...). Black women in particular are often portrayed as highly sexualized - but when this type of sexualization is also an objectification, it becomes even more dangerous, and forecloses the possibility for black women to empower themselves. If anybody is having trouble coming up with an example of how we all perpetuate stereotypes, think about the way we arbitrarily assign gender to other anonymous drivers when we're in our cars; next time you get cut off, you'll probably noticing yourself blaming either a man or a woman, specifically, for their bad driving. |
| back to top |
| Posted 11 months ago As a woman of color I have noticed that there is a constant struggle to overcome stereotypes portrayed in the media that are perceived as true. One of the things I practice is not giving someone the reaction they expect. Sometimes people do and say things just to get a rouse out of you. Also, it is important to take a look at the top level positions at your company are there any women of color. |
| back to top |
| Posted 11 months ago I think AM_Morgan's point about stereotypes is key. in general, I find it difficult to strike a balance between reacting as i am genetically and culturally programmed to, and not giving into expected behaviors, but once I catch on that I am just being provoked, I try not to react at all. |
| back to top |
| Posted 8 months ago I think in general there are stereotypes between all cultures about each other. Women do it to each other, and so do men. I have felt on certain occasions to be exoticized by others because I have a Spanish last name and exude an air of "ethnicity". People in general are curious to know what I am and are surprised when they guess wrong. |
| back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago As a woman of color I would have to say, that yes we do get slammed with the old double negative. I've experienced
|
| back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago If people took the time to interact with other races, learn their cultures, and embrace their differences alot of the stereotypes would not surface. As an African-American female, I hate it when I get upset and I hear that is a typical reaction you would get from my gender and race. If they analyzed the situation, anyone would have reacted the same way. Understand the situation, not base it on my gender or race! |
| back to top |
| Posted 7 months ago My experience is an interesting one to share here, I think. I am white, but Latin American. When people meet me in person, I have never felt discriminated against. But when they see my name on a résumé or e-mail first, when they meet me, I have gotten some surprised looks or, "I thought you were Hispanic," which I felt was really inappropriate. As is usually the case in these types of situations, ignorance has a lot do with it: Many people don't know that a lot of white people live in Latin America (in addition to blacks, Asians, etc.). |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago I believe, women in general face more discrimination in the work place than men do. As an example, look at the bad press that Senator Clinton, who is educated and accomplished in her field, has received in the media. Men are not willing to cede the political power of the presidency to a woman. I think women of color face less discrimination than their male counterparts. Men still rule the business world despite our many accomplishments. As a gender we have not come as far as we would like to believe. True equality in race or gender will never happen unless we can all see with a blind eye. Donna Life is short. Embrace your friends and family with love. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago Absolutely...and this includes all women of color:
etc...etc...If you identify as Woman of Color this incudes you...however, it is more detriment to those that are visibly a woman of color... and here was my take on it: (in excerpt)
McIntosh: “White Privilege”
The purpose of this essay was for a White woman to acknowledge, define and bring societal awareness to the fact that the notion of White privilege is a reality in society. The author studied the privileges of men and noticed that there were many similarities of the privileges afforded White people. So in part, she began to study and research the privileges and extensions of not only, male privilege, but also, White privilege. She studied how each had its advantages and specific degrees of seperation. The essay in addition, provided a long list of privileges she believed are afforded her simply because of her race, and skin tone. She acknowledged that these privileges are consistently given to those of the White race on many levels; however, some White people take advantage of those privileges, while others like her feel the need to expose and eradicate the practices of White privilege.
First she decided to look at herself and identify the daily affects of White privileging that existed in her life. Then, she came up with a lengthy list of privileges that as far as she could discern none of her Black associates could rely on in their daily lives. The privileges ranged from: having the choice to only interact with those exclusively of your own race, to representation in media, to living in a neighborhood where you would be accepted, to more serious issues like. THe more serious list included: the guarantee that her (white children) children will receive a proper education, and also that being White meant she did not have the pressure to represent her entire race. There were many issues of privilege based on politics, education, daily interpersonal communication and interaction that a person of the White race is privilege to have, which she listed, from not worrying about IRS audits to feeling welcome in most public places and institutions. Finally, she broke down the components of White privilege by daily effects. And ended by anh explanation, that she didn’t even realize the effects of White privilege until she had written them down.
This was a personal account and process by which the author learned not only, her acceptance and compliance of White privilege, but also, she learned she had been afforded something that she had not earned just as men had not earned many privileges they are afforded simply based on gender. She became aware that many opportunities are handed out to people based entirely on their race. She further realized that being White was asset and made her free to explore any avenue she chooses regardless of dominant culture or traditional norms. Yet, in the end she says that this privilege is all encompassed and can result in empowerment that is not deserved and makes the White race able to over dominant in society.
This article brought to light many issues dealing with White privilege. It was a hard reality check for the author as well as a disapproving stand to take. She made the point that being oblivious to White privilege is just as negative a reinforcement as male advantage, which is similarly a continued strong viewpoint in society. In the end, she ask the question how long will it take to awaken the consciousness of White people to realize that the White privilege they use and impose on others is a construct needed rebuked and reconstructed to include a more balanced system of awards.
Some White people understand the damage they cause by exerting their White privilege, and are not truly oblivious as our author may have been to such privilege. Some White people have become accustomed to this privilege and take advantage of it on a daily basis. Some White people understand and choose not to care of the consequences of accepting their White privilege. And some White people will never admit anuything of the such exist. Those White people do not see privilege as unearned rewards; but instead value privilege as a customary way of life. The author stated herself that she hadn’t realized some of the privileges of being White until she actually sat down and starting thinking of them. And it wasn’t until then, when she was amazed how many she came up with. This acknowledgement in itself leans credence to the fact that some White people --- even those more actively engaged in social and civil inequities are not privy to becoming adapted to and using their own race to afford them privilege, be it unconsciously or consciously. The author stated that she had reflected on such privilege only when she understood male privilege, and how its patriarchal power was abused by men, and was mostly used to oppress other’s – that she identified her own White privilege as just as damaging to the society she lived. She then decided that like some men she would try to become self-aware, and rectify the privilege status of unearned power. She came to understand the attitudes of those without such privilege. In the end, McIntosh was made more self-aware and more conscientious of her Whiteness and the privilege afforded by the color of her skin; which in no means to her, should her Whiteness be allowed to benefit her with unearned rewards. Caveat: It also made me think of the privilege we as light skinned, or mixed Black people are afforded on a daily basis especially in our own culture, but also, in society as a whole. Some of the same privileges are awarded but not on such powerful scale as with White privilege. There are advantages we can take simply because of the pigment of our skin as well, or the texture of our hair. Yet by no means does this privilege equal or qualify or become institutionalized to the extent of the power and privilege of being White.
ARW (C) 2008 Even A Bird Without Wings Yearns To Fly. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago Beautifully posted Artisst! Ann M. Evanston, MA CEO Zena Enterprises
|
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago Maybe I shouldn't be speaking on this topic, since i'm not going to jump on the wagon and say "Amen, sister" to this stuff. I think "people of color" or whatever description they aren't offended by today are overprivileged. Before you jump on my back and call me a racist, please read on. They have so many scholarships, types of assistance, and other privileges, they can't help but be successful. So, they didn't get a job? It is automatically because somebody is racist, right? Well, maybe someone else was truly more qualified. And God forbid, the person was white. Do you know what irritates me most about that, is that people expect to be given a job or opportunity just because they are of a different color. They are so used to being "handed things" in life, and learning that if they don't get what they want, it's because they are black, or hispanic, or whatever race they may be. When I was an E4 in the Navy, I was married to an E3, and we had 2 babies, yet we couldn't get qualified for WIC because we made $40 more than the income limit. Yet, a black female E-6, who was married to another E-6, qualified. Yet they made over $1000/mo more than we did. Another example, I worked at a helicopter squadron with a black female E-4 who cried that she was "being worked like a n----r" (HER WORDS, NOT ANYONE ELSE'S), so she would be leaving by 5pm everyday while the rest of us were still up on aircraft working 12 hour days to avoid having her file an EO complaint. She was transferred up to a job in Training, which helped her with promotion, while the rest of us just did our jobs. We had 7 or 8 other blacks in maintenance and she was the only one crying racism. We all had the same job. She wasn't treated any worse than the rest of us, she was actually treated better because people had to walk on eggshells around her, because if you get an EO complaint against you, it sticks, and YOU have to prove it's not true! So I can honestly say, I'm not racist, at least I wasn't until I was surrounded by people like that. I don't know what I owe people like that. They say it's because of the slave days, but I never owned any slaves, and until I meet someone who was a slave, then that's when I'll give my regards and respect. They earned it. Until then, no matter what race or ethnicity you are, you need to work to earn respect (in this country anyways). Enough with the handouts and assistance to those who don't need it! Leave it for those who DO NEED IT! I'm truly sorry if this offends anyone, but I just feel for people who work their butts off and don't get a bit of help, yet there are those who are just plain lazy and expect others to support them. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago Blking74: Affirmative Action has its problems but it was instituted for a reason -- to alleviate structural discrimination of minority groups. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago There is a difference between an individual and a group. Your example is of individuals that take advantage of affirmative action blking74, and you perfectly say that there were 7 others that were black and did not do what she did. So to stereotype a WHOLE group of women, because of one or two bad apples is sad. I am involved with a black man, and as he has tried to climb the corporate ladder, there are fewer and fewer role models for him. He, just like you works really hard, he just like you earned his degrees, and has worked hard and stayed loyal, and he has watched people with less education and experience get jobs he is better qualified for. Discrimination - hard to say no. In addition, the military is a hard place to compare in this discussion. It, as an organization has created levels of discrimination quite blatantly, which increases issues these issues. Gays and women are just 2 examples in RECENT history of discrimination in the military.
Ann M. Evanston, MA CEO Zena Enterprises
|
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago I wasnt going to reply to this post at first because generally when someone writes something of this nature with obvious prejudice and visceral sentiment, there is something more behind them and their story/ies...and I am not trying to give a session or philosophize with someone whose mind is made up...Then I read it again, and said not this time, will I be quiet. I will not make a debate, of which I could based off the incorect information you provided, but instead, I will just tell it like I feel it. No offense intended, but what is intended is that perhaps you will read this and see how your ill words effect a Black person who was not offended, but interested to know that still today this type of notion of inequality and division still exist in the hearts and minds of our society and people. And just maybe as you suggested you shouldn't speak on this topic, because it is one you are not well versed. Yet, I respect your opinion and fervor as such. May I suggest you read your own words and listen to them closely and become more self-aware of how, what, and why you think and feel this way. As Ann suggested, if it is based on your singular experience only, then I will suggest, again, that perhaps you consciously take into account the whole of your situation, and develop a mental picture of why these minor incidences made you feel a certain negativity and why it yielded such a negative response from you.
blking74 says ...
forgive the typos....was kinda typing fast...smiles... Even A Bird Without Wings Yearns To Fly. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago This is really a conversation worth continuing. There are structural inequalities in our country that are slowly improving, yes, but that still do prevent people of certain socio-economic standing -- including ethnicity/race -- from advancing. -------- To answer the question asked in this thread: Yes it is harder for women of color. It's hard for women, period. Add on non-white status, and it's even harder. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago As a woman of color I do know that it is generally harder for us, especially in the workplace. In the three last jobs, white females with no working experience or qualification for the specific position were offered and given substantially more pay. In confronting management, i have come to realized that, while the woman of color is qualified and performs above par on the job, it is the belief that this same woman is still not smart enough to know that they are being treated at a sub-par level when compensation comes into play. It is even harder, if you are a foreigner, of color and woman. Three strikes. VRJ |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago How much longer will it take until it is generally and widely accepted that being a woman, a foreigner, of color, having a foreign passport, a disability of some sort, etc. etc. etc. is not a DETRIMENT or IMPEDIMENT of any kind, but instead something that will only make that person a STRONGER candidate for any job, given the varied life experiences, outlooks, and ideas they can bring to the table? Is the fact that the Democratic Party just nominated a black man, born of a mother from Kansas and a father from a tiny tribal village in Kenya, a sign that perhaps the United States at-large is finally moving to embracing multi-raciality, globalism, multi-culturalism? Daniela
|
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago It is most definitely harder for a woman of color. We catch it in society, the workplace, home, and each other(I mean other women). It seems every where we are there are those that feel we want something for nothing, wil do anything for money, are overpreveiliged,oversexed and /or lazy. It is one of the reasons I rarely socialize, I dislike preconceived ideas about me. I try very hard not assume that just because of a persons color or gender they are better off or worse off than me. I keep hearing about how much better I have it than others, yet I am a 43 year old woman just trying to survive, get a job and keep my family together. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago What are tangible, clear-cut steps women of color can take to dispel preconceived notions about them based on race/ethnicity (in personal and professional situations)? Daniela
|
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago Perhaps, but it is also often harder for women who are overweight, large breasted, blonde, not blonde, tall, short and have acne as well. I think it depends largely on the quality of the individual doing the hiring. To the people who discussed knowingly making less money, have you gone to your manager and presented your achievements and why you should be making a certain amount? If so and you had a good argument and still did not get a raise or a legitimate reason for not giving you one, then I suggest you contact your local NAACP representative. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago This is such a hard topic for me, I've had moments that I've felt that women of color has had a raw deal, but then others when I feel like color is used to their benifit. I think that management is forced to look at diversity and if she/he does not have enough diversity, people want to know why. Even in Girl Scouts we get hit every year wanting to know how to get more of this race or that to join so our diversity numbers are better. If we spent less time calculating all the diversity then we may be able to spend more time making sure those we have working for us deserve to and those we are hiring are really qualified for the job. But heck what do I know I'm just a Scottish, Irish, English, Icelandic, Sweedish, French, German, Cherokee American who didn't qualify for any scholarships, did not finish college and is still paying off the student loans. Oh and yes I am large breasted and was told I got a job one time because the boss like looking at my boobs. Even if that wasn't the reason, it ruined any chance I have of being taken seriously. |
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago I think that both race, name, and looks are an issue. I have seen my manager reject applicant resumes based on a name that is hard to pronounce, out of the norm, or points to a certain race. I have seen my manager talk in a more positive way about someone who he thinks looks more appealing or attractive. We had a young lady here who had all of the qualifications and experience for the job she was hired, but bc of her very slight ticking (teret's syndrome) she was fired. Management told us it was due to overhead, but it didn't make sense bc we were still hiring at the time. She was persistent and kept calling the owner (who hadn't made the decision to fire her) he rehired her, now she works in another field, but has proved herself to be great at her job. Application/Resume's should be judged based soley on qualifications, history, and abilities and anyone who goes beyond this is wrong. "Your absence has gone through me, Like thread through a needle. Everything I do is stitched with its color." ~William S. Merwin
|
| back to top |
| Posted 6 months ago
"Your absence has gone through me, Like thread through a needle. Everything I do is stitched with its color." ~William S. Merwin
|

