Group Forums >> News for the Thinking Class >> Scream Bloody Murder: an eye opening look at genocide in our generation

+2

Scream Bloody Murder: an eye opening look at genocide in our generation

144 Views
9 Replies Flag as inappropriate
Quiet_time_max50

93 posts

back to top

Posted about 1 month ago

 

I just got the word that a good friend of mine finally got the green light to do a special on something she's been working on for quite sometime. She's CNN's International Correspondent Christine Amanpour. Her special is on Genocide. This is the article from the Washington Post she just sent me:


Offered perhaps as a grim antidote to all the chirpy, cheery holiday specials glutting the airwaves this time of year, "CNN Presents: Scream Bloody Murder," a definitely unflinching history of genocide, premieres tonight on CNN. The network's chief international correspondent, Christiane Amanpour, conducts the class, calling genocide "the world's most feared crime."



Genocide might also be called the unthinkable inevitable, since it is always condemned when discovered and yet continues to recur, wiping out entire populations, entire generations, entire cultures. The word was not invented until 1944, Amanpour says, but of course, there were examples of genocide long before it was identified.


The vilest, most infamous and most organized commission of this ultimate crime was, inarguably, Adolf Hitler's attempt to eliminate all Jews from Europe during World War II. Amanpour says the United States and its allies were aware of the slaughter but "refused" to bomb the death camps or, as many people advocated, destroy the railroad tracks leading to them. A Holocaust survivor says Hitler's anti-Semitic rampage "wasn't a priority" for the Allies -- although after the war, the crime and some of the criminals were dealt with at Nuremberg.


Elie Wiesel is the world's best-known authority on the Holocaust, but he is also an advocate for other cultures wracked by genocide. He is seen early in the program during a segment on the genocide in Cambodia at the end of the Vietnam War. "Nobody believed us," an anguished priest laments, and Wiesel understands. "Better not to believe," Wiesel says, "because if you believe, you don't sleep nights." The nightmare that the Turks visited upon the Armenians is also covered, though briefly.


Later, Amanpour takes George Herbert Walker Bush and his administration to task for failing to intercede when Saddam Hussein rained terror down on Iraq's own citizens, the Kurds, in the late 1980s. Bush later turned the proverbial blind eye to mass murder in Bosnia, Amanpour says, with the president growling at a news conference that "we are not going to get bogged down in some guerrilla warfare."


Although Bush ignored the slaughter of the Kurds, he grabbed a saber and began rattling it when Saddam invaded Kuwait -- and thus threatened the flow of oil and wealth out of the Mideast. Now that was going too far! Oil-rich Kuwait plucked at Bush's heartstrings as the dying Kurds had not: "We're dealing with Hitler revisited," he declared, adding one of his trademark threats, "This will not stand."


But Amanpour is just as hard on Bill Clinton for his response to Rwanda when the military was found to have murdered "hundreds of thousands" of men, women and children there. The Clinton administration's policy was "a failure," Amanpour says, and she includes a scene from a Clinton news conference in which he treats one of her accusations snidely: "There have been no 'constant flip-flops,' Madame," he huffs. His indignation seems false and hollow now.


CNN is celebrating 25 years of reports by star reporter Amanpour, although to attach a documentary on genocide to anything resembling a "celebration" is not very good form. Nor is it encouraging to hear Amanpour implicitly praising herself and her own courage when dealing with genocide of recent years: "Day after day, I reported the story," she says of one crisis -- and later, she notes of the shelling of Sarajevo, "I was there, reporting on the scene."


The use of a dramatic musical score, though restrained, comes across as another unnecessary intrusion; pictures as dramatic as those showing the victims of genocide don't need any underscoring or audio hype.


Amanpour ends the program with a look at the United Nations and its role in preventing and condemning genocide throughout the world, a role she contends the organization has seldom embraced with zeal. In fact, Amanpour says, "the United Nations is powerless to force its members to act even in the face of mass murder." The special is timed to the upcoming 60th anniversary of the U.N. convention on genocide.


Some may find the program tough to take at holiday time, but in fact it seems especially powerful during a season in which "peace on Earth" and "good will toward men" are being extolled from street corners.


"Scream Bloody Murder" isn't subtle, but then the subject rather precludes subtlety -- and instead demands the kind of doggedly powerful approach that Amanpour brings to it.


 


CNN Presents: Scream Bloody Murder (two hours) airs tonight at 9 on CNN.


I have to work tonight but I'm going to TiVo this show. This is the type of stuff I like to have on hand to talk to my niece and nephews about. I take life and introduce it as history to them so that they'll have a firm footing and won't be swayed by every piece of information that comes down the pike just because it's dressed in black or white or democrat or republican. I want them to do what seems so unnatural now and that is to THINK for themselves.


That's the article and here's my question: Do you think the Obama Administration will do anything differently? I hope you guys find time to watch. Chrissy's a great woman.



sknight

Jane_max50

773 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

A friend of mine fled to the US from Cambodia during the genocide there.  As far as she knows, her siblings did not survive.  Another friend survived the concentration camps in Germany.  His parents and siblings all died.


We've also sat back while genocide occurs in Darfur.  It is a pretty helpless feeling to contact our officials, including the President, and get no response on something of such importance, when they're quick enough to answer on smaller matters.


Jane G. Chambers
Transformed by God's love and grace

Scanpic_max50

466 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 month ago

 

If I've understood Obama and his agenda correctly - it will be our goal to work with other countries - and absolutely address genocide wherever it may occur - I heard him say it won't be tolerated - but I believe we will all need to work together.  I also think I read somewhere that Susan Rice is very sensitive to this particular issue.

Quiet_time_max50

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 month ago

 

I truly hope our generation is able to do something about this. I watched Chrissy's piece last night and I thought I'd have a lot to say but in all honesty...I'm at a loss for words. It really woke me up and that was her intent. Right now I think I'm just on the hunt for solutions.


any ideas?


sknight

Avt_brandylynn1975_large_max50

779 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Solutions.......I don't know.  This subject must stay in the global limelight.  So many people either forget or choose not to think of it.  Saddam Hussein and the war we are in now is an example.  America was upset with the war against Hitler as well while it was being fought.  It is a terrible, horrendous crime against humanity, and very difficult to end. 

Scanpic_max50

466 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 month ago

 

Any solution has to include (somehow) the peaceful resolution of the underlying cause of the violence - huge task - especially when I think about how it's even possible for anyone to view another human life as "disposable".


It has to stopped first and foremost and at the same time we need to create the world-wide dialogue -- everyone has to buy-in.


Is that naiive?

Quiet_time_max50

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted about 1 month ago

 

I don't think any of the ideas expressed in this forum is naive. It helps when we can talk about these things. When I was stationed in Germany in the early 90's I was surprised at how the Germans could deny the Holocoust and say that it was "a figment of the American imagination." even though consentration and death camps were all around them. I got to visit  Dachaue and I didn't make it past the "baby aquarium" In that glass box were toys, dolls, trucks, bottles, pacifiers....etc. and I literally ran back to the front gate and hurled.


My tour guide was insensitive enough to say that amercans always have a weak stomach.


 


storm


sknight

Seal_close_up_max50

60 posts

back to top
+1

Rated: +1 | Posted 22 days ago

 



Genocide...a word that sends shivers down my spine.   Many of my generation and those after me have great difficulty understanding how a narrow way of thinking so gripped a nation and caused so many deaths and atrocities in Germany.  It is hard to grasp how easily this happened to educated people.   Our history professors tried as they may to help many of us understand what simply cannot be fully understood unless you were there or know of someone that had.  It was unfathomable to me how this happened.


When Oprah first started her "Book Club"  one of her first suggestions was Stones from the River  By Ursula Hegi.   Reading this book unraveled the mystery to me.  It showed how easily a way of thinking can be adopted by a few and then imposed on many.  It is an insidious growth of evil which systematically tore apart a group of people, a nation, and then became one of our darkest moments in history. 


I would encourage people of all ages to read this book.  This book reveals just how easily this happens in society...and it can happen again...and is still occurring in the world.  It made me more aware of what I read, what message I send to others, and how our media truly shapes what we hear or see.  In this day and age so many people have become content to be spoon-fed information by the media and simply do not think for themselves.  On another side, it also reveals how much people do not want to see.  Averting one's eyes to a subject does not make it go away.  Many Americans are tired of "policing" so many other nations, tossing money at causes that is often misused,  and sacrificing our youth to fight wars that feel like they are not ours....yet we cannot as a society ignore the atrocities.


The book looks at the Nazi movement from the point of view of a young woman that is not Jewish, but suffers from dwarfism.  It reveals that the Nazi movement was far more reaching...beyond religious points of view to include the abuse of anyone deemed imperfect.   Through this book you watch and see how easily this way of thinking quickly started in youth groups and spread. 


This reminded me of how during my first year in college so many years ago, I was approached by so many different religious and political groups, all reaching out for young impressionable minds.  Our children today still have this happening in our colleges all across America.  We would be naive to think it only happens in American colleges.  It explains a lot about how educated young people are tossing themselves with bombs strapped to their chests at cars overseas.   There are many ways the attitudes of our youth can get twisted.


So many young people enter college looking for a sense of direction or belonging.  That is exactly how genocide...the narrow-mindedness of it...spreads.   I think if more people read this book they would have a much better understanding of genocide is and how it happens today.  I have sent my children off to college with the insight that they already belong, have direction and need not look towards others to fill that need.  They each read this book and felt quite differently about what they hear and see in the media...and the current "popular" way of thinking. 


I'd like to encourage everyone to read this book.  It should be required reading. 


 

Quiet_time_max50

93 posts

back to top
Rate

Rate This | Posted 19 days ago

 

Thank you for sharing that. I'll definately pick the book up.


sknight